The Good: The atmosphere is in the Goldilocks zone, not too loud, not too quiet, just right. The staff was personable, willing to suggest their favorite dishes, and did not rush us at all. Later in the evening there was live music that wasn't over bearing which was a definite plus. For dishes I recommend the Risotto Di Mare, Margherita Pizza, or their special.
The Bad: None that I could find.
Overall: I will definitely return to Carelli's, I can see why it was voted best Italian restaurant in Boulder.
Visited July 2016
All USA
The Good: The atmosphere is in the Goldilocks zone, not too loud, not too quiet, just right. The staff was personable, willing to suggest their favorite dishes, and did not rush us at all. Later in the evening there was live music that wasn't over bearing which was a definite plus. For dishes I recommend the Risotto Di Mare, Margherita Pizza, or their special. The Bad: None that I could find. Overall: I will definitely return to Carelli's, I can see why it was voted best Italian restaurant in Boulder. Visited July 2016